Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lark Evermore's avatar

Can we say that antidepressants work for some people and not for others? If so, wouldn't a clinician's time be better spent trying to discern who needs to be on an antidepressant and who doesn't?

Isidore Bloom's avatar

After I developed stupor, intention block, episodes of delirium, and autonomic dysfunction from SNRIs, and long QT syndrome from antipsychotics, it was easy and tempting to think that I’d been written off for chemical sedation as “schizophrenic and incapable of insight” and/or “borderline, thus stupid and incapable of considering the humanity of others”. But it’s been half a decade since I tapered off all the meds that weren’t working and stayed on the ones that were, and now I’m far more concerned about misrepresentations of psychiatric conditions as incurable, untreatable, and incapable of mysterious spontaneous remissions. I took meds, I tapered off meds, I did a lot of self-directed therapy (DBT and also CBT aimed at OCD) and generally worked hard to improve.

And now I’m better enough that a friend who’s trained as a psychologist was shocked to learn I’d been frankly delusional and suicidally depressed less than a decade ago.

I think the impression of futility that unwarranted rejection of even the possibility of antidepressants working for some people is pretty concerning. I held on grimly throughout my 20s because I’d read the suggestion that sometimes, schizoaffective and bipolar disorders level out and attenuate in one’s 30s and 40s. It turned out true for me. I don’t think I’d be here if I hadn’t been able to read and understand the research.

Ready for more?