12 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. Misha's avatar

Thanks, Awais.

Both DSM and HiTOP have something in common - no mention of the brain. I don’t know how long these competing classifications (from both APAs) can keep the charade.

DSM offers some practical value as a communication tool, and it is readily accessible to the curious public. Also, the insurance companies and the CDC can collect data (thanks to the "S" in its name), and the FDA can give pharmaceutical houses a standardized language for advertising.

HiTOP can’t claim even that. The scheme is so convoluted and impractical that even seasoned psychiatrists can’t make heads or tails of it, not to mention primary care docs and OBGYNs who see most psychiatric patients.

DSM is ubiquitous but still makes a lousy taxonomy. For instance, PTSD diagnostic criteria list 20 symptoms and 4 situations, which in various combinations make 636,120 (!) possible diagnostic presentations. Lupus was called a disease with a thousand faces; how about more than 600,000? Imagine a medical disorder with the same conundrum. Or take, for instance, the DSM criteria for major depressive disorder (MDD) offering nine sets of symptoms and calling out five for the diagnosis. That makes more than 250 possible combinations, which means two people who do not have a single common symptom can still be diagnosed with major depression. How can you treat both of them with the same “FDA-approved” for major depression medications?

BTW, the third contender, RDoC, is as good as dead. The team bit off more than they could chew and got stuck in a tangle of social categories, disjointed symptoms, neurocircuits, neurotransmitters, receptors, and genes mixed with NIMH bureaucracy and politics. The statue of Laocoön and His Sons comes to mind.

All told, psychiatry painted itself into a proverbial corner. There is, however, a model that might work. It served physical medicine well for centuries. APA actively resists it despite its own statement that ”psychiatry is the branch of medicine.“ I am curious why they avoid mentioning the brain in its classification. A specific phobia, perhaps.

There is another point of confusion permeating both classifications. Despite the superficial appearance of continuity, etiology, pathology, diagnosis, and treatment are only loosely connected. We don’t treat etiology, not only in psychiatry but in the rest of medicine. The best we can do in psychiatry is to restore some missing functions and alleviate debilitating distress. The classifications should help us do that instead of muddling the picture with vague, contradictory symptoms and irrelevant categories, which continue to plague DSM.

The Comments format limits getting deeper into the medical model for psychiatric disorders. Another time perhaps.

maybeiamwrong2's avatar

I feel like some things are worth pointing out:

First, HiTOP does mention the brain in their overview articles, as one stream of converging data. See for example:

https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-081219-093304

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32394571/

Second, in those articles, they also point to preliminary evidence for it being more acceptable to clinicians than are traditional diagnoses.

Third, RDoC was never meant to be a taxonomy of psychopathology but a framework for guiding research. See: https://www.nimh.nih.gov/research/research-funded-by-nimh/rdoc/about-rdoc

Dr. Misha's avatar

First, I googled - [HiTOP] and [brain] - but couldn't find any connection, including a long article in wikipedia. I didn't see the link in the referenced article either and was not suprised given the origin of the proposed classification.

Second, the claims of HiTOP's acceptability to clinicians notwithstanding, the scheme lacks practical application. It's contrived and confusing. The dualism of internalizing vs. externalizing dimentions reminds of the archaic neurosis-psychosis division. HiTop is a flash in the pan, with no foundation and structure, and will be gone before most psychiatrists will learn about it.

Third, in early days, RDoC made a clear push toward classification and even as recently as 2020 had the ambitions. Read "The role of RDoC in future classification of mental disorders" written by one of its founders, Bruce N. Cuthbert, PhD https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7365298/

Also, the article from the 'green journal' in 2010 (authored by Thomas Insel, M.D., Bruce Cuthbert, Ph.D.,) says it all: "RDoC classification rests on three assumptions. First, the RDoC framework conceptualizes mental illnesses as brain disorders. In contrast to neurological disorders with identifiable lesions, mental disorders can be addressed as disorders of brain circuits. Second, RDoC classification assumes that the dysfunction in neural circuits can be identified with the tools of clinical neuroscience, including electrophysiology, functional neuroimaging, and new methods for quantifying connections in vivo.

Third, the RDoC framework assumes that data from genetics and clinical neuroscience will yield biosignatures that will augment clinical symptoms and signs for clinical management. Examples where clinically relevant models of circuitry-behavior relationships augur future clinical use ... analogous to what is done routinely today in many other areas of medicine."

In another article, https://www.nimh.nih.gov/archive/news/2013/dsm-5-and-rdoc-shared-interests written in May, 2013 (the birthday of DSM-5), Tom Insel wrote ""RDoC is an attempt to create a new kind of taxonomy for mental disorders by bringing the power of modern research approaches in genetics, neuroscience, and behavioral science to the problem of mental illness."

Clearly, from the get go, RDoC saw itself as an alternative (to DSM) classification. In the NIMH vs. APA contest, the latter won and the former backed off from the original claims.

maybeiamwrong2's avatar

The push-back on RDoC is very fair, I am not well read in it and thus have no historical perspective. To me it seems fine to change your scope/mission statement in the process.

On the brain link, Kotov et al. (2020) literally has two sections titled "Neural substrates: neuroimaging" and "Neural substrates: neurophysiology". Kotov et al. (2021) has one section titled "Neuroscience". Does that not count as mentioning the brain?

And as far as I am aware, HiTOP is already used in practical application. Not sure what you mean by dualism of internalizing vs. externalizing, they are seperate dimensions that show some correlational pattern and thus are modeled as sharing some variance and containing some unique variance.

Awais Aftab's avatar

Thanks for this discussion! I personally think there is no reason for us to be devoted to any one particular diagnostic framework. We need to take what is valuable from any approach and use it together in a way that makes the most sense. What we might call nosological pluralism.

HiTOP and RDoC have their own advantages and disadvantages. HiTOP doesn't explicitly refer to neurobiology, but it actually has a fair bit of validity evidence, which HiTOP group presented in a series of papers in World Psychiatry. It takes time and energy, so it's not very clinician friendly at the moment, and it's unclear how well it guides treatments or changes outcomes. Likely more suitable for academic settings, but time will tell. It will be more useful for quantitatively minded psychologists. Would be a hard sell for primary care and psychiatry.

I recently wrote about RDoC's conceptual evolution as well: https://awaisaftab.substack.com/p/rdoc-more-than-a-decade-later-humbler

Dr. Misha's avatar

I agree, changing the scope, even the structure of the proposed project is the natural evolution of an original idea. Presently, RDoC is struggling. It's too elaborate and entangled. It will take years, perhaps decades, for all pieces to come together. The RDoC team started with a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle with more than half of the pieces missing. Instead, they should've tackled a 500-piece puzzle first.

HiTOP’s claim of being based on "neural substrates" is a sale pitch. Nothing in its model suggests the connection. HiTOP is written for therapists who don’t need neuroanatomy and imaging studies to write their "diagnostic formulations" and start psychotherapy. Their therapeutic targets don’t change with variations in clinical presentation.

I’ll be happy to expound.

Scott's avatar

"The classification is ultimately pragmatic. What method of categorization we prefer will depend on what we want to accomplish and how we can accomplish it."

The admission that classification is “pragmatic” is a direct endorsement of instrumentalism. But this raises a teleological question: Instrumental toward what end?

We can define the final cause as “the absence of dis-ease.” We can then define “problems” (mental disorders) as whatever obstructs that end. But because our understanding of evolution is contingent and shifting (because species are evolving, duh), these definitions are never fixed. They are temporary instruments for a moving target.

We are approaching DSM-6. Who here believes we will ever reach a “DSM-FINAL”? Who is prepared to defend an eternal taxonomy of suffering, for the rest of this universe? If we aren’t prepared to admit that our categories are transient —rising and falling across social contexts —then we are pretending our tools are "eternal truths". I'm saying psychiatry needs to embrace a dynamical universe where even “scientific laws” are provisional, not final.

The Fast-Slow-Defense model of psychopathology partially fulfill these criteria.

The real danger of instrumentalism isn’t that it’s pragmatic. It’s who the instrument serves: if it only serves the institution (insurers, legal systems) rather than the agent, there will be backlash. Because then, gents will inevitably invent their own causal languages of suffering to make sense of their lives. This is precisely why religious frameworks often “work” : they offer a language of meaning that serves the agent’s individual need for coherence and action, not the institution’s job security role.

According to Aristotle, who popularized the very concept of constitution, institutions emerge from the individual dynamics of persons interacting with each other. Therefore, individual persons constitute institutions a-priori. Therefore, institutions are not prime movers and should not be considered as such. The people trying to "rescue institutions" are failing to realize that "institutions" do not refer to individual physical people who can be held accountable. For every institutional scandal, no one goes to jail.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 5, 2023
Comment deleted
Dr. Misha's avatar

Two main reasons (among many) prevent modern psychiatry from embracing the evolutionary origin of psychopathology. Neither one has anything to do with racism.

The first is practical. Despite clear evolutionary origin of arousal, emotions, automaticity, and reality testing, to name a few, we don't have tools to treat etiology. Instead, we treat symptoms, and the evolutionary role of menatl diseases becomes purely academic. The second is the antagonism toward the evolutionary model from the powerful psychoanalytical community, which insists that psychiatric diseases emerge from early traumas and unresolved conflicts that soil an otherwise clean (tabula rasa) baby psyche. We can't have both, can we? If mental illness is an evolutionary construct, what’s there to "analyze?" Evolution throws a monkey wrench (no pun intended) into the orthodoxy.

BTW, 'Why We Get Sick: The New Science of Darwinian Medicine' by Randolph M. Nesse and George C. Williams is an insightful book about evolutionary medicine. In addition, there are several books on evolutionary psychiatry and articles by Randolph M. Nesse, a psychiatrist.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 29, 2023Edited
Comment deleted
Dr. Misha's avatar

I was intrigued by your "I disagree we "don't have tools to treat etiology." Do we have them? Please share. Perhaps (I am reading between the lines) you believe the analysts can get to the "bottom of it."

You shouldn't hang on to the word analytical as pertaining to the analytical couch. I use the term in a broader sense. You wouldn't deny that a psychodynamic (formerly analytical) mindset dominates in "any University in North America" and the Western World, would you?

I guessed from your writing that you conflate psychoanalysis and psychiatry into one discipline. They are not. The former is a philosophical, unfalsifiable, and self-referential endeavor, while the latter is "the medical specialty concerned with the study, diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of mental, behavioral, and personality disorders." according to APA, which supposedly knows. The analysts don't treat mental diseases.

I didn't read Del Giudice's book (I've read other authors on the subject and wrote one myself). However, I perused the linked review article by Scott Alexander and would characterize his (SA's) comments about evolutionary psychiatry (part II) as naïve and, at times, silly. I also read his notes on genetics and had the impression his knowledge of the subject is mainly Mendelian. He also uses quotes from Del Giudice's book. If the rest of the book is like these, I doubt I'll be reading it in the future.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 30, 2023
Comment deleted